1 Review
9
| Fanedit Name: | Star Wars: The Clone Wars - Episode I: Army Of The Republic |
| Review Date: | 2023-09-24 09:00:30 |
| Reviewer: | cavy8 |
| Overall Score: |
| 0 |
| A/V Quality: |
| 0 |
| Audio Editing: |
| 0 |
| Visual Editing: |
| 0 |
| Narrative: |
| 0 |
| Enjoyment: |
| 0 |
| Review: [Copy of my review from IFDB, may not reflect any updates if they have been made] Smudger9 has done what I had previously thought impossible: He made the earlier parts of The Clone Wars TV series into an enjoyable viewing experience. I have frequently expressed my deep-seated hatred for the beginning of the series, and was really surprised by what was done in this wonderful edit. I'll go through my favorite things about the edit before I get to my minor complaints. Pros: -What I really like in this edit is how smudger9 took multiple arcs and was able to mesh them into a single cohesive story. -I found myself much more attached to characters (specifically the clones of Domino Squad) due to his editing. -Some really awful story arcs were cut (Jabba's son, anyone?) -Ashoka wasn't pushed to the front. While I have nothing against her, she wasn't important to the story of this edit and would've detracted from the plot. -Most of the editing was extremely well done. It was barely noticeable mostly. Cons: -There were a couple of points where you could tell a conversation had been modified. It would have a slightly noticeable visual and audio glitch when it happened. However, it was rare. -There was a poor ratio of action vs. character development, but I can understand this since most of the character development happens in cut story arcs. However, it would've been nice if a little more could've been preserved. All in all, a wonderful edit that created a movie worthy of any Star Wars collection. |
Comments (0) | Was this review helpful? 0 0