1 Review
9.4
| Fanedit Name: | Star Wars: Andor: Chapter I - The Reckoning |
| Review Date: | 2024-05-16 09:54:27 |
| Reviewer: | Acbagel |
| Overall Score: |
| 9.4 |
| A/V Quality: |
| 9 |
| Audio Editing: |
| 9 |
| Visual Editing: |
| 9 |
| Narrative: |
| 10 |
| Enjoyment: |
| 10 |
| Review: I finally got a chance to watch MR's Andor: Chapter 1 last night. Wow! What a difference the narrative pacing makes. Removing all the Syril scenes through Ferrix makes it feel like Cassian is actually the main character. I was getting major spy film vibes throughout the whole film rather than the slow unfocused drip of the show's original pacing. This is a format that is FAR more rewatchable than the D one. Here's my official review: Audio/Video Quality: This edit was required to be streamed through Google Drive, so they typical degradation from that process is to be expected, but it presented as a typical 1080p film without any major quality issues. I was not once distracted due to a lack of quality in the A/V department. Maybe I'm getting spoiled by modernity, but ever since getting a 4k monitor and working with 4k footage, 1080p has started to look blurry to me haha. So since Andor does exist in 4k and that would be peak quality, I will rate this category of the edit a 9/10. Visual Editing: Throughout the entirety of the film I spent many moments going, "Did MR remove a scene here or not?" And that's a good thing! The majority of new transitions were completely smooth and unnoticeable, making me have to go back to the changelog to see if there was in fact a scene in between. The addition of subtitles to the Kenari flashbacks was incredible (I will write more on this later), though I did notice a typo which distracted from the moment. There were maybe 3-5 transitions where I could tell that a change had been made due to some visual jarring (the biggest offender IMO was right before the title card), but overall the large majority of the film was top tier visual editing. I score this category a 9/10 as well. |
Comments (0) | Was this review helpful? 1 0